Where these films came from
A surprising amount of Hindi cinema is European and American material arriving at two or three removes — and almost never directly. Erich Kästner's 1949 German novel about separated twins became a Disney film, then a Tamil film, and only then a Hindi one. Conan Doyle's hound crossed into a Bengali novel, then a Bengali film, then Hindi, and by the end the moor was a marsh and the hound was a woman singing.
This page is the record of those journeys as we find them. Each line is a film we hold and the thing it came from, with how it got here. Most of the sources are not in this catalogue yet — the intention is to hold them, and the links below are written so that when Dumas or Kurosawa or the Tamil original arrives, it connects to what is already here rather than sitting on its own.
Taken from a novel, a play or another film
The source, and how it travelled.
-
36 Ghante (1974) → The Desperate Hours (Joseph Hayes, 1954) not in this catalogue yet
Remade from William Wyler's 1955 film of Hayes's novel and play - and unusually for this catalogue, taken straight from the American film with no Indian-language version in between. Not held.
-
Anurodh (1977) → Deya Neya (1963, Bengali) not in this catalogue yet
Shakti Samanta rebuilt the Bengali original in Hindi, which was his working method for much of his career.
-
Bees Saal Baad (1962) → The Hound of the Baskervilles (Arthur Conan Doyle, 1902) not in this catalogue yet
Conan Doyle three removes down: his novel became Hemendra Kumar Roy's Bengali Nishithini Bivishika, which became the 1951 Bengali film Jighansa, which became this. The moor is a Bengal marsh and the hound is a voice.
-
Betaab (1983) → The Taming of the Shrew (William Shakespeare) not in this catalogue yet
Loosely - two people who cannot be in a field together without a quarrel. Javed Akhtar's first script after the Salim-Javed split.
-
Chori Chori (1956) → It Happened One Night (Frank Capra, 1934) not in this catalogue yet
Capra's film transplanted whole - the runaway heiress, the reporter, the bus, the blanket between two beds.
-
Devdas (1955) → Devdas (Sarat Chandra Chattopadhyay, 1917) not in this catalogue yet
The Bengali novel, filmed more than a dozen times in several languages. Bimal Roy's is the version the others are measured against.
-
Do Kaliyaan (1968) → Lisa and Lottie (Erich Kastner, 1949) not in this catalogue yet
Kastner's novel reached Hindi by three steps: Disney filmed it as The Parent Trap in 1961, AVM remade that in Tamil as Kuzhandaiyum Deivamum in 1965, and this is the Hindi version of the Tamil one.
-
Do Kaliyaan (1968) → The Parent Trap (1961) not in this catalogue yet
The Disney film between Kastner's novel and this one.
-
Gora Aur Kala (1972) → The Corsican Brothers (Alexandre Dumas, 1844) not in this catalogue yet
Dumas's novella about twins separated at birth, arriving through the 1971 Tamil film Neerum Neruppum.
-
Gumnaam (1965) → And Then There Were None (Agatha Christie, 1939) not in this catalogue yet
Christie's novel, loosely - the island, the strangers, the accusation and the count going down, with songs added.
-
Hum Dono (1961) → Uttarayan (Tarashankar Bandyopadhyay) not in this catalogue yet
Dev Anand read the Bengali novel and bought the film rights from Bandyopadhyay himself; his brother Vijay Anand wrote the screenplay from it, loosely. The novel is not held.
-
Hum Dono (1961) → Uttarayan (1963, Bengali) not in this catalogue yet
The same Tarashankar Bandyopadhyay source, filmed in Bengali two years after this. Not held.
-
Hum Dono (1985) → Sommokadidi Sokokadidi (Telugu) not in this catalogue yet
A remake of the Telugu film, from S. L. Kalyani's story. Not held.
-
Hum Hindustani (1960) → Basu Poribar (1952, Bengali) not in this catalogue yet
The Bengali original.
-
Inkaar (1977) → High and Low (Akira Kurosawa, 1963) not in this catalogue yet
Kurosawa's film, which was itself Ed McBain's novel King's Ransom - the kidnappers take the servant's son by mistake and the rich man must decide whether to pay.
-
Inkaar (1977) → King's Ransom (Ed McBain, 1959) not in this catalogue yet
The McBain novel underneath Kurosawa's High and Low.
-
Judaai (1980) → Aalu Magalu (1977, Telugu) not in this catalogue yet
A remake of the Telugu film, from M. Balamurugan's story. Not held.
-
Mahaan (1983) → Shankar Guru (1978, Kannada) not in this catalogue yet
An official remake of V. Somashekhar's Kannada film - the Hindi title keeps the two sons' names inside the original one. Not held.
-
Maqsad (1984) → Mundadugu (1983, Telugu) not in this catalogue yet
Remade from the Telugu film, with the Paruchuri Brothers' story and screenplay carried over. Not held.
-
Meera (1979) → The poems of Meerabai (16th century) not in this catalogue yet
The songs are Meerabai's own devotional poems, set by Ravi Shankar - so the film's score is sixteenth-century verse rather than written for it.
-
Mr. India (1987) → Jasoosi Dunya (Ibn-e-Safi) not in this catalogue yet
Mogambo was built out of Ibn-e-Safi's Urdu pulp detective novels, which supplied a great deal of the Hindi thriller's furniture.
-
Padosan (1968) → Pasher Bari (1952, Bengali) not in this catalogue yet
The Bengali film between Chowdhury's short story and this.
-
Padosan (1968) → Cyrano de Bergerac (Edmond Rostand, 1897) not in this catalogue yet
Rostand's play - the lover who woos through another man's mouth - reaching Hindi through Arun Chowdhury's Bengali short story and the 1952 film Pasher Bari made from it.
-
Sachaai (1969) → Pandhayam (1967, Tamil) not in this catalogue yet
A remake of the Tamil film, produced by M. C. Ramamurthy, nephew of M. G. Ramachandran. Not held.
-
Shehzada (1972) → Idhu Sathiyam (1963, Tamil) not in this catalogue yet
A remake of the Tamil film, from Ra. Ki. Rangarajan's story. Not held.
Remade elsewhere
Films here that were made again in another language.
-
Aah (1953) → Ah Bu Dunya (1965, Turkish) not in this catalogue yet
Turkey remade this twice - as Ah Bu Dunya in 1965 and Bos Cerceve in 1969.
-
Anari (1959) → Pasamum Nesamum (1964, Tamil) not in this catalogue yet
The Tamil remake.
-
Anuraag (1972) → Anuragalu (1975, Telugu) not in this catalogue yet
One of four remakes - Telugu with Sridevi, then Malayalam as Raagam, Kannada as Chiranjeevi and Tamil as Neela Malargal.
-
Arth (1982) → Marupadiyum (1993, Tamil) not in this catalogue yet
The Tamil remake; the film also prompted the Pakistani Arth 2 in 2017.
-
Benaam (1974) → Thirugu Baana (Kannada) not in this catalogue yet
Remade in Kannada with Ambarish and Aarati in the parts Amitabh Bachchan and Moushumi Chatterjee play here. Not held.
-
Betaab (1983) → Samrat (1987, Telugu) not in this catalogue yet
Remade in Telugu, and again in Kannada as Karthik in 2011.
-
Bobby (1973) → Parvaz dar Ghafas (1980, Persian) not in this catalogue yet
The Iranian remake.
-
Brahmachari (1968) → Enga Mama (1970, Tamil) not in this catalogue yet
Remade in Tamil in 1970 and in Telugu as Devudu Mamayya in 1981. Neither is held.
-
Chirag Kahan Roshni Kahan (1959) → Maa Babu (1960, Telugu) not in this catalogue yet
The Telugu remake, a year later.
-
Dhool Ka Phool (1959) → Jeevana Teeralu (1977, Telugu) not in this catalogue yet
The Telugu remake.
-
Ghar Ek Mandir (1984) → Anni (Tamil) not in this catalogue yet
Remade in Tamil with Mohan and Saritha. Not held.
-
Gumnaam (1965) → Naalai Unathu Naal (1984, Tamil) not in this catalogue yet
The Tamil remake.
-
Joroo Ka Ghulam (1972) → Anukoolakkobba Ganda (Kannada) not in this catalogue yet
Remade in Kannada. Not held.
-
Shor (1972) → Osai (Tamil) not in this catalogue yet
Remade in Tamil. Not held.
Dubbed into another language
-
Aah (1953) → Prema Lekhalu (Telugu) not in this catalogue yet
The Telugu dub did better than the Hindi original, and Raj Kapoor thanked Telugu audiences with a song in Shree 420 two years later.
Reused in a later film
Not a remake - the story was taken up again and rebuilt.
-
Brahmachari (1968) → Mr. India (1987)
Brahmachari's premise - a penniless man keeping a houseful of orphans he cannot afford and will not give up - is recorded as the inspiration for Mr. India nineteen years later. Not a remake; the same situation, rebuilt with an invisibility watch and Mogambo in it.
-
Deedar (1951) → Do Badan (1966) not in this catalogue yet
Manoj Kumar took Raj Khosla to a rerun of Deedar and the two of them reworked its storyline into Do Badan; G. R. Kamat wrote the screenplay from it. Shakeel Badayuni wrote the songs for both, fifteen years apart. Not a remake - the same engine, rebuilt.
-
Karan Arjun (1995) → Madhumati (1958)
The reincarnation machinery Hindi cinema has run on since Madhumati - a death, a rebirth and a debt settled across two lives - in its loudest commercial form.
-
Madhumati (1958) → The Reincarnation of Peter Proud (1975) not in this catalogue yet
Wendy Doniger has suggested Madhumati may lie behind this American film, which was itself remade in Hindi as Karz in 1980.
-
Madhumati (1958) → Om Shanti Om (2007) not in this catalogue yet
Om Shanti Om took its climax closely enough from Madhumati that Bimal Roy's daughter accused its producers of plagiarism.
45 sources and remakes on this page, 43 of them pointing at a work we do not hold. That second number is the useful one: it is the list of what to find next.
This page covers where films came from and what came from them. The rest of the research network — the same writers, composers and editors turning up across the catalogue — is on each film’s own page, under Where this leads. 155 connections are recorded altogether.